Reviews policy
Drafted — pending legal review
We wrote this page ourselves and a lawyer has not reviewed it yet. It describes how IncaTrail.com works today and applies from the effective date below. It may change after review; every change is dated in the history at the end.
How ratings from other websites are shown and labelled, how our own ratings will be built from reviews submitted here, how operators are ordered, what “Not yet rated” means, and how an operator can dispute a rating.
Where reviews stand today
Traveller reviews open after operator listings do. Until then, an operator page may show a rating published on another website, with its source and the date we checked it. That rating is not ours and we have not verified it. Our own rating appears only once we hold enough reviews submitted here; until then we show “Not yet rated”.
Our ratings and other sites’ ratings
We never write or buy reviews, and we do not copy reviews from other websites. Where we show a rating published elsewhere, we name the source and the date and present it as that site’s rating, not ours. Our own rating is built only from reviews submitted here under this policy. Payment never changes either one.
How operators are ordered
By default, the directory lists operators by the highest rating we cite for them from another website, highest first. Operators with no cited rating come after those with one. Payment never changes this order.
Who may review
Only a traveller whose trek with that operator actually took place may review it. We confirm the trip from the operator’s booking record or from evidence the traveller sends us and we check, such as a booking confirmation.
Verification labels
Each review shows a label that says how the trip was confirmed: from the operator’s record or from evidence we checked.
Every opinion is published
We publish positive, mixed and negative reviews alike. We never hold back, delay or bury a review because it is critical.
When we remove a review
We remove or edit a review only for a stated content reason:
- it is abusive, hateful or threatening;
- it reveals someone’s personal data;
- it is fake, or written by someone who did not take the trek;
- it is written by an insider without the insider label;
- it is unlawful or infringes someone’s rights.
Statement of reasons
Every removal is recorded in our moderation log with the reason. We tell the reviewer what we did and why, and the reviewer can ask us to look again.
No incentives for reviews
No reward, Trail Stamp, level, badge, prize or discount depends on writing a review or on what a review says. Questions we ask on a review about porter conditions feed only anonymous totals.
What operators can and cannot do
An operator may reply publicly to a review of its company. An operator can never block, edit or pay to remove a review, and can never offer anything in exchange for a review or for changing one.
Operators may pay us to advertise (Verified Owner, Pro, pay-per-click). That never changes ratings or order.
Insiders
Staff of IncaTrail.com, owners and staff of an operator, and their families are insiders. An insider cannot review that operator; any review an insider writes elsewhere carries an “insider” label.
Reporting a review
Anyone, including the operator, can report a review they believe breaks this policy by writing to inquiries@incatrail.com. We decide under the same rules for everyone and tell both sides the outcome. How we make money, and why it never touches ratings, is set out in the disclosure. This policy is a draft written in-house and pending legal review.
Change history
- First published draft, written in-house and pending legal review.
Questions about this page? Write to inquiries@incatrail.com.